明日战记观后感

《明日战记》的问题可以说是一模一样，而因为机甲科幻更难做所以这些问题反倒更严重了。

1.同样的两条线，指挥部和作战小队。其实指挥部的情节占比相当小，电影基本上一直都是更烧钱的作战小队情节，而这部分的呈现并不一直都是好的。同样近景镜头怼的太近，《明日战记》不但怼的近还特别晃，我不清楚是导演没做好项目管理且摄影师没经验还是为了掩盖特效不足，这一点非常影响观感。可能之后有了网络版观感会好一些，这个帧数不足的荧幕、一些观众比如我还要戴着眼镜看，体验糟糕。其实稍稍放慢些速率观感会好很多，我不清楚是不是后期调快过，不是说初版112分钟终版99分钟吗。

2.特效不足主要表现在电影开头这个与刀刃相对的刀把上。讲真，开头出品人与主要演职员这部分不如不插入那些特效不足的镜头（特别是那个天台那架直升机），直接此次行动的电子地图，然后主角开始讲述故事背景，这样观感肯定好不少。

在出了logo后特效就变稳定了，除了刘青云与刘嘉玲的某两个镜头有抠图的感觉外都还好，特别是之后机甲战斗时效果特别好，算是把钱花在了刀刃儿上。

其实也不能说是特效不足，应该是团队经验不足，因为抠图调色这种事情一些up可能做得都比电影团队好。

3.剧情上就更值得说了。郭帆把“流浪地球”这个故事讲得很好，懂得扬长避短，而《明日边缘》的剧情可以说完全相反、相当理工男，什么样就是什么样，硬核又鸡肋，有槽点无BUG。这方面之后会详解。

还有观众必须要了解的一点是，机甲科幻比太空科幻烧钱且难拍太多太多。机甲科幻你既要讲究物理规律又要符合机械运动，还TM要顾及到人与周遭环境的互动、正常情况下不同物体之间的碰撞、高速运动下的碰撞。

动的永远都比静的难搞，而动的所谓“难搞”又分了太多太多类。可能《流浪地球》和《独行月球》的工业表现迷惑了很多人，以为我们的电影工业真的发展到了可以随便拍科幻片的水准，希望一部《明日战记》可以让更多人认清现实。

二.纵向对比

这次对比的国外电影可就不是什么《火星救援》和《星际穿越》了，而是《环太平洋》和《明日边缘》——和机甲沾边的我也就知道这两个，再说就是《铁甲钢拳》和《变形金刚》了。

不了解的观众可能想象不到，其实机甲电影并不比其它种类的特效大片花钱少。《环太平洋》成本1.9亿刀，《明日边缘》成本1.78亿刀，就连最便宜的《铁甲钢拳》成本都要1亿刀。而《明日战记》的成本是多少？网传有说3亿的有说4亿的，那也就是《铁甲钢拳》的一半或者多一点（不会有人要和我说什么汇率换算吧？），而《铁甲钢拳》和《明日战记》的打斗密度差别有多大我就不多说了。

这还不算，此次是我们国内第一次搞机甲科幻，也就是说是需要试错成本的，别说机甲科幻的试错成本了，硬科幻电影又有几个拍过、几个团队搞过？

所以说这个和国外电影的纵向比较除了可以比比成本、让我们知道什么叫巧妇难为无米之炊外(再说咱还不算巧呢），其他一切对比都是无意义的。

三.剧情

有剧透，不过这剧情剧透也没什么所谓。

说真的，我这个剧情第一观感第二的人对这部电影的剧情方面没有任何想要吐槽的地方，我只想给觉得有槽点的人梳理一下。

第一个让我疑惑的地方，开始作战任务前不疏散群众。当我以为这是个大槽点、又是在搞老美那一套时，一看电影里给出的时间，三小时，哦那没事了。三个小时疏散已经没有了现代通讯网络的城市居民确实是不可能的。

二，为什么作战小队知道了一切都是李升的阴谋时第一时间是联系了李升本人而不是告知谭冰呢？会因为这点疑惑的老兄搞清楚啊，这个地方李升是老大，谭冰是空降，且李升还是TM拯救人类的“天幕”创造者，你拿什么和人家搞对立？（当然这也和背景设定没说清楚有关）

剧情很简单，简单到说都不用说的程度，电影也不是根据剧情分的Part，而是场景和别的。

开头到泰来那最后一架战斗机坠毁是第一部分（空中，普通作战服），出了医院副本郑重生带人入队是第二部分（医院，外星生物，外骨骼战甲出场），回去取什么液是第三部分（废墟巷子，外骨骼战甲），路上对战穷奇和机器人是第三部分（高速路，外骨骼战甲对战机甲怪兽），最后是结尾对战刑天与机器人。

然后是两条感情线，通讯兵和通讯员的爱情，泰来和小女孩的亲情。前者融入了故事线里，而后者是背景的铺垫，两者均是对人物的刻画与丰富，所以也不算鸡肋。（这里要说个好玩的，通讯员那个外貌和扮相太像我前同事了，疯狂出戏MD）

总之，剧情就是送的。关注剧情不如挑一挑外骨骼战甲或者机甲怪兽“不科学”的地方（如果能被挑出来的话），还是那句话，太理工了。

四.演职员

吴炫辉导演。说实话导演在这部电影里就和剧情一样，像是送的。项目管理，拍摄到上映过了四五年；镜头调度指导，之前横向对比的时候提了；剧情就更不用说了。

两位编剧。就算剧情改了好几轮且有不少人参与，可背景设定表现不出来除了编剧来背这锅我另外找不到合适的人选。

众位演员，只想提一下通讯兵……的扮相。其实这一定程度也反映了整个项目的情况，理工男说了算。如果换一个稍微多些商业头脑的人，这个演员一定会找那种与通讯员能组成俊男靓女搭档的，好吸引更多受众特别是女性，相应的整部电影也不会安排这么紧凑。

最后，古仔。如果说这部电影最大的亮点是两场有关外骨骼战甲的打戏的话，那对整部电影影响最大的人无疑是古天乐。这点就不说了，具体看这个UP的视频。

The problems of "Tomorrow's War" can be said to be exactly the same, and because the mecha sci-fi is more difficult to do, these problems are more serious.

1. The same two lines, headquarters and combat squads. In fact, the proportion of the plot of the command is quite small. The movie has basically always been a more expensive battle team plot, and the presentation of this part is not always good. Also, the close-up shot is too close. "Tomorrow's War" is not only very close, but also very swaying. I don't know whether the director did not do a good job in project management and the photographer was inexperienced or to cover up the lack of special effects, which greatly affects the perception. It may be better to have an online version in the future. This screen with insufficient frames and some viewers such as me have to wear glasses to watch it, and the experience is bad. In fact, it will be much better to slow down the speed a little bit. I don't know if it is adjusted faster in the later stage. Isn't it 112 minutes for the first version and 99 minutes for the final version?

2. The lack of special effects is mainly manifested in the knife handle opposite the blade at the beginning of the movie. To tell the truth, it is better not to insert those scenes with insufficient special effects (especially the helicopter on the rooftop) at the beginning of the production and the main actors and staff, and directly to the electronic map of the operation, and then the protagonist begins to tell the background of the story, so the look and feel must be much better. .

After the logo was released, the special effects became stable. Except for some two shots of Liu Qingyun and Carina Lau, they were all good. Especially after the mecha battles, the effect was very good. It was a waste of money. .

In fact, it can't be said that the special effects are insufficient, it should be the team's lack of experience, because some ups may do better than the film team in things like cutout and color correction.

3. The plot is more worth mentioning. Guo Fan tells the story of "The Wandering Earth" very well, and knows how to make use of strengths and avoid weaknesses, while the plot of "Edge of Tomorrow" can be said to be the complete opposite, quite a man of science and technology. This will be explained in detail later.

Another thing that the audience must understand is that mecha sci-fi burns more money and is much harder to shoot than space sci-fi. In mecha sci-fi, you must pay attention to the laws of physics and conform to mechanical motion, and also take into account the interaction between people and the surrounding environment, the collision between different objects under normal circumstances, and the collision under high-speed motion.

Moving is always more difficult than static, and the so-called "difficult" of moving is divided into too many categories. Maybe the industrial performance of "The Wandering Earth" and "Lone on the Moon" confuses a lot of people, thinking that our film industry has really developed to the level where we can make sci-fi films casually. I hope a "War of Tomorrow" can be recognized by more people Reality.

2. Vertical comparison

The foreign movies compared this time are not "The Martian" and "Interstellar", but "Pacific Rim" and "Edge of Tomorrow" - I know these two as well as mechas, and besides " Iron Fist" and "Transformers".

Uninformed audiences may not imagine that, in fact, mecha movies do not cost less than other types of special effects blockbusters. "Pacific Rim" costs 190 million dollars, "Edge of Tomorrow" costs 178 million dollars, and even the cheapest "Iron Fist" costs 100 million dollars. And how much does Tomorrow Wars cost? There are rumors on the Internet that some say 300 million and some say 400 million, which is half or a little more than "Iron Armored Steel Fist" (no one wants to tell me about the exchange rate conversion?), while "Iron Armored Steel Fist" and "Tomorrow" I won't say much about the difference in the fighting density of "The Legend of War".

This is not to mention, this is the first time in our country to engage in mecha sci-fi, which means that the cost of trial and error is required, not to mention the trial and error cost of mecha sci-fi. How many hard sci-fi movies have been filmed and how many a team?

Therefore, the vertical comparison between this and foreign films is meaningless, except that it can compare the cost and let us know what a clever woman can do without rice (and we are not a coincidence), all other comparisons are meaningless.

3. Plot

There are spoilers, but the plot spoilers don't really matter.

To be honest, I, the first and second person in the plot, have nothing to complain about the plot of this movie. I just want to sort out those who think there are some points.

The first thing that puzzled me was not to evacuate the crowd before starting the combat mission. When I thought it was a big slop and I was doing the old beauty thing again, I looked at the time given in the movie, three hours, oh that's fine. It is indeed impossible to evacuate a city dweller without a modern communication network in three hours.

Second, why did the combat team contact Li Sheng himself instead of telling Tan Bing when they knew that everything was Li Sheng's conspiracy? The dude who will be puzzled by this will figure it out. Li Sheng is the boss of this place, Tan Bing is the airborne, and Li Sheng is also the creator of the "sky curtain" that TM saves mankind. What do you use to oppose others? (Of course, this is also related to the background setting not being clearly stated)

The plot is very simple, so simple that it goes without saying, and the movie is not divided into parts according to the plot, but scenes and others.

From the beginning to the crash of the last fighter plane in Tailai is the first part (air, ordinary combat uniform), and the second part is the second part (the hospital, alien creatures, exoskeleton armor), and go back What liquid to take is the third part (ruin alley, exoskeleton armor), the road against Qiongqi and the robot is the third part (highway, exoskeleton armor vs mecha monster), and finally the ending is against Xingtian and the robot.

Then there are two love lines, the love between the messenger and the messenger, and the love between Tyler and the little girl. The former is integrated into the story line, while the latter is the foreshadowing of the background. Both are the characterization and enrichment of the characters, so they are not tasteless. (I want to say a funny thing here. The appearance and appearance of the correspondent is too similar to my former colleague, and he is crazy about playing MD)

In short, the plot is sent. It's better to focus on the plot than to pick out the "unscientific" aspects of exoskeleton armor or mecha monsters (if they can be picked out), or that sentence, too technical.

4. Actors

Directed by Wu Xuanhui. To be honest, the director is the same as the plot in this movie, like a gift. Project management, it took four or five years from filming to release; lens scheduling guidance, which was mentioned in the horizontal comparison before; not to mention the plot.

Two screenwriters. Even if the plot has been changed for several rounds and many people participated, but the background setting can not be expressed, I can't find a suitable candidate except the screenwriter to take the blame.

All the actors, I just want to mention the appearance of the signal soldier... In fact, this also reflects the situation of the entire project to a certain extent, and the engineer has the final say. If it were someone with a little more business savvy, the actor would definitely find a partner who could form a handsome man and a beautiful woman with the correspondent, so as to attract more audiences, especially women, and the corresponding whole movie would not be so tightly arranged.

Finally, Guy. If the biggest highlight of this movie is the two battle scenes about exoskeleton armor, then the person who has the greatest influence on the whole movie is undoubtedly Louis Koo. I won't talk about this, just watch this UP video for details. Author: lqfewe https://www.bilibili.com/read/cv17932047/ Source: bilibili